Skip to content
Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Ice Cream made in a Ninja CREAMi, served
AI-generated photo, not of a test batch

Sugar-Free Peanut Butter

Creamy, salty-sweet peanut butter ice cream with no added sugar, topped with chopped roasted peanuts.

Hands-on
5 min
Freeze
24 h
Program
Ice Cream
Makes
4 servings6 servings

Good forKids’ favorites

Pin it

Nutrition

Per 100 g, estimatedPer serving (¼ of a 473 ml16 oz tubpint, about 123 g), estimated

178kcal
4.9 gProtein
15 gFat
5.9 gCarbs
3.8 gSugar
219kcal
6 gProtein
19 gFat
7 gCarbs
5 gSugar

Whole tubpint: 874 kcal, 24 g protein1311 kcal, 36 g protein (709 ml24 oz). Contains: Peanuts, Milk. The sweetener is counted as allulose; xylitol adds more calories.

Ingredients

6 ingredients
Measure in
TubPint size

Tap an ingredient when it is in the bowl

smooth peanut butter (natural, just peanuts and salt)allulose or a 1:1 granulated sweetenervanilla extractfine saltwhole milkheavy cream max fill
smooth peanut butter (natural, just peanuts and salt)allulose or a 1:1 granulated sweetenervanilla extractfine saltwhole milkheavy cream max fill

456 of 473 ml684 of 709 ml

In the tubpintScale reads

TubsPints
1
Remix in the Pint Builder

Steps

  1. Whisk 60 g smooth peanut butter55 ml smooth peanut butter¼ cup smooth peanut butter90 g smooth peanut butter85 ml smooth peanut butter⅓ cup smooth peanut butter, 70 g sugar-free sweetener90 ml sugar-free sweetener¼ cup + 2 tbsp allulose or a 1:1 granulated sweetener105 g sugar-free sweetener130 ml sugar-free sweetener½ cup + 1 tbsp allulose or a 1:1 granulated sweetener, 1 tsp pure vanilla extract1 tsp pure vanilla extract1 tsp vanilla extract1½ tsp pure vanilla extract1½ tsp pure vanilla extract1½ tsp vanilla extract and a pinch of fine salta pinch of fine salta pinch of fine salta pinch of fine salta pinch of fine salta pinch of fine salt in a large bowl.
  2. Whisk in 250 ml whole milk250 ml whole milk1 cup + 1 tbsp whole milk375 ml whole milk380 ml whole milk1⅔ cups whole milk a little at a time until smooth, then whisk in 100 ml whipping cream100 ml whipping cream¼ cup + 3 tbsp heavy cream150 ml whipping cream150 ml whipping cream⅔ cup heavy cream.
  3. Pour the base into an empty tubpint, up to the max fill line. Put the lid on and freeze on a level shelf for 24 hours.
  4. Take the lid off, set the tubpint in the outer bowl and lock it into the machine. Run Ice Cream.
  5. If it looks crumbly or powdery, add 15 ml whole milk1 tbsp whole milk1 tbsp whole milk25 ml whole milk1½ tbsp whole milk1½ tbsp whole milk and run Re-spin.

To serve: Top with chopped roasted peanuts.

My notes

Tips

  • Use natural peanut butter with no added sugar. Stir the oil back in before you measure it.
  • Allulose keeps it softest. Where it is not sold, use a granulated sweetener that measures like sugar and plan on a Re-spin.
  • For chocolate chunks, add 30 g chopped sugar-free chocolate with Mix-in.

Why it works

Peanut butter brings fat and protein, so this tubpint needs less cream than most, and allulose keeps it soft and scoopable.

New recipes in your inbox

What to freeze for the weekend, new recipes and the taste of the week, in one short email at most once a week. Unsubscribe any time.

Plus a free texture cheat sheet when you sign up: the quick fix for every texture problem, on one page.

You will get an email to confirm first. How we handle your email

Ratings & reviews

Loading reviews…

Questions & answers

Loading questions…

Which CREAMi do you have?

The model number is on the bottom of the machine. Your choice is saved in this browser.

Measure in

Allergies

Hide recipes that contain these, everywhere on the site. Always check ingredient labels too.

Hide